10 Reasons You’re Not Getting Hired after the Interview

Not getting hiredYou thought the interview went well. You expected to go on to the next round. Maybe even get a job offer.

Instead, even after following up in a professional manner, you’ve heard nothing.

What went wrong? Why are you not getting hired?

To help you learn what mistakes might be keeping you from finding job search success, the team at Business Collective by Young Entrepreneur Council (YEC) asked their members this question:

Question: What is a major personal brand turnoff when hiring new employees and why?

Here’s what they had to say…


Wearing Inappropriate Attire

Jared Brown“We’re really not asking for much in the startup scene — casual or business casual is the norm, with suits only required at very formal events or meetings. When a potential new hire can’t even get this one right — they dress sloppy, look haphazard — it’s a bad sign. If you don’t pay attention to the details of how you look, how can you fine-tune the details of the job I’m supposed to give you?”

–Jared Brown Hubstaff



Beck Bamberger“Uptalk is that appalling and flat out annoying increase in pitch at the END of a sentence that shrinks your confidence and authority. It makes firm statements sound like questions. We deal with hard-charging entrepreneurs, some double the age of my staff, and uptalk is one sure way to make yourself seem small and lacking authority.”

–Beck Bamberger BAM Communications


Showing Up Too Early

alisha-Navarro“We’ve heard the mantra “if I’m not early, I’m late,” but showing up more than 10 minutes early is at least as bad as (if not worse than) showing up late in the eyes of a busy entrepreneur. If I set an interview for 10:00, that means that I have planned my morning around that interviewee showing up at 10:00. If he/she shows up at 9:00, it only shows that the person is unable to follow instructions.”

–Alisha Navarro 2 Hounds Design


Stressing Self-Promotion Over the Team’s Success

Kofi-Kankam“While it’s an admittedly fine line to walk, I am immediately turned off when a prospect is in such heavy self-promotion mode that they don’t highlight their place within the team and their team’s ultimate success as opposed to just their own. It just reminds me that if they join our team, their advancement will reign supreme over concern for our company’s progress. So, we’re not for them.”

–Kofi Kankam Admit.me


Sharing TMI on Social Media

Dave-Nevogt“Everyone has hilarious, silly or slightly risqué photos and status updates on their own social media, and that’s okay — but if I can Google you and see all that without having to connect first, it’s a problem. Especially for marketing or sales, I want to hire someone who understands the difference between sharing drunk photos with their friends and inadvertently sharing them with business contacts.”

–Dave Nevogt Hubstaff.com


Showing Up Late

Mark-Samuel“Being late. Don’t ever be late to an interview. After that, I could name 10 things that don’t work for us, especially in this new tech age where everyone is on their phone or checking their phone, etc. Main point: Stay focused on why you came to interview, why you want to work here, what you can offer us.”

–Mark Samuel Fitmark


Ripping on Previous Employers

Andrew Howlett“Too often someone comes in for an interview and takes to discrediting or ripping on a previous employer for a variety of reasons. Not sure if they think I’ll be impressed or think they were too amazing for that previous employer, but it only makes me think, “What will they say about me?” Don’t do it. Even if it ended badly, say nice things or say nothing at all.”

–Andrew Howlett Rain


Using Clichés

Firas-Kittaneh“Applicants who have clichés or worn-out idioms in their résumés and cover letters seem uncreative and unoriginal. In the startup industry, the best companies have the most innovative, top-tier employees. The best way to show me that you have the capacity to be new and inventive is to simply write and speak clearly without relying on crutches like clichés or idioms.”

–Firas Kittaneh AstraBeds


Agreeing with Everything You Say

Andy-Karuza“Most people who will agree with everything you say don’t have a firm foundation of beliefs or a backbone. They are likely just trying to tell you what you want to hear so they can get what they want, which is a big red flag for the reality of their personal commitment to your team and helping the company achieve its goals. If you stand for nothing, you’ll fall for anything.”

–Andy Karuza FenSens


Being a Know-It-All

Cameron-Gawley“The person who admits and is open to what they don’t know is one who we are always looking for. They are the ones that will grow into the best of employees.”

–Cameron Gawley BuzzShift 



For this post, YouTern would like to thank our friends at Business Collective!


BusinessCollective Logo



This entry was posted in Job Interviews and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.