Top Recruiters Share Their Phone Interview Pet Peeves

STEVE CARELLMany employers use the phone interview as an initial screening; this short conversation decides who moves on to the next round… and who doesn’t. Unfortunately, many professionals don’t take the phone interview as seriously as an in-person interview.

Big mistake.

We spoke with dozens of hiring managers who said they wish more candidates treated phone chats the same as in-person meetings. And we asked them: “What are the major phone interview mistakes made by candidates?”

Here’s what they said:

1. Zero Enthusiasm and Confidence in Your Voice

Hiring managers want to hear a strong, positive voice as soon as you pick up the phone.

Consider answering by mentioning your name: “Hello, this is Bob” can avoid initial awkwardness and help things move along. You’d be surprised how much a great start can shape the rest of the phone interview.

To put it bluntly: “If you aren’t confident in the phone interview, the hiring manager is going to assume you aren’t confident in person, so you probably won’t get a second chance to make a better impression,” says Jené Kapela, who not only owns her own consulting firm specializing in leadership but also has had over 10 years of experience as a hiring manager.

To convey confidence and enthusiasm— always be professional, energetic and positive in your tone of voice. Smiling can help boost your tone and project your voice positively.  Practice your pace.

Remember: “You want this to be the best phone call they’ve had all day,” says Emily Ceisel, HR practitioner and hiring manager.

2. Interview While Driving, Outside or in Public

First of all, driving while interviewing can be ridiculously dangerous! “The candidate is distracted and at times very unclear,” says Gail Tolstoi-Miller, CEO at Consultnetworx, a national  consulting firm and Speednetworx, a speed networking event company for Fortune 500 companies.

CieselThis happened to Lisa Quast, a former executive vice president and general manager of a Fortune 500 company with over 20 years of hiring experience, as well. When interviewing a candidate, “I could hear everything, from the traffic noise, to ambulance sirens, to the job seeker stopping at a service station and filling their car with gas,” Quast says.

We get that you might be super busy, but always make time to take the call in a private, stationed area with strong reception. Making it tough for your interviewer to hear you is a fast way to lose their interest!

3. Forget to Turn Off All Other Notifications

Honestly, “landline is always preferable,” Tolstoi-Miller says. It simply removes all risk of low reception and offers minimal distractions. If you have to use your cell phone, make sure you’re not distracted by incoming emails, texts, Facebook notifications, Instagram hearts, etc. (the list can go on for miles).

4. Assume the Interviewer Is Male

This is a very specific example of a larger, important lesson of researching before the phone interview! Elle Kaplan, founding partner and CEO of LexION Capital Management, is often mistaken for Mr. Kaplan by candidates. It’s pretty off putting for her, considering her firm is the only 100 percent woman-owned asset management firm in the US. Talk about embarrassing!

“My bio and picture are on the [company] website,” Kaplan says. Overall: “Doing background research before you have an interview is essential,” she adds.

Avoid making these gross factual errors by researching the company thoroughly. Check out the company website, social media profiles, recent news articles and LinkedIn members to double check names and events. Also, check out great interview tips for each company on CareerBliss reviews to get an even bigger leg-up.

5. Cut Answers ShortSTAR

Since you can’t really see the interviewer’s reaction, it can be hard to gauge whether or not you’re doing well or answering thoroughly enough.

One great way to preemptively work through this is to use the STAR method as suggested by Ceisel.

“Explain the Situation, your Task, the Action you took, and the Result,” Ceisel says. “Most often, candidates forget to share the result, which is the most important part.” It helps to print out a hard copy of a list of the achievements that you want to make sure you cover in the conversation.

6. Be Unprepared for the Most Common Interview Questions

Since phone interviews are usually the initial test to see if you fit the basic criteria, be prepared to handle those questions effortlessly. These are the questions that you should have pat down, courtesy of Steven Raz, cofounder of Cornerstone Search Group, a national pharma recruiting firm:

  • What type of position are you looking for and why?
  • Why do you want to leave your current job (or previous job)?
  • When are you ready for an in-person interview? When would you be able to start?
  • Do you have two professional references?
  • Do you have any questions? (Pro tip: These 5 Amazing Questions Will Impress Your Interviewer)

By avoiding these pet peeves, you are sure to impress the recruiter or hiring manager during the phone interview… and move on to the next round of interviews!





For this post, YouTern thanks our friends at CareerBliss!




RitikaAbout the Author: Ritika Trikha is passionate about scoping out top-notch job advice in the career-sphere to help you find a job you love. Ritika has 99 problems but an unhappy career isn’t one! She’s a writer and an optimist (and Jay Z’s No. 1 fan). When Ritika’s not writing stellar advice articles, she’s obsessing over social media. Connect with her via CareerBliss Tumblr, Pinterest and Google+! And follow Ritika on Twitter!



This entry was posted in Job Interviews, Job Search and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.