Recycling Generational Stereotypes: Does This End with Gen Y?

“Talkin’ ‘Bout My Generation” (Again, and again, and again…)

Have you seen the news? Read the articles? Heard the talking heads?

They say young people are “lazy” and “entitled”. It’s said that young people – the entire generation – will never amount to much.

I came across a Time Magazine article the other day that really bothered me. It was another older person talking down to my generation. The article described us this way: “They have trouble making decisions. They would rather hike in the Himalayas than climb a corporate ladder.” It said we’re a generation that “postpones growing up” pointing out that “fully 75% of young males 18 to 24 years old are still living at home, the largest proportion since the Great Depression.” We’re apparently the “New Petulants” because we “can often end up sounding like whiners.”

What?! We’re “whiners” just because we don’t want to live the same lives as our parents?!

Regarding employers, the article said “Companies are discovering that to win the best talent, they must cater to a young work force that is considered overly sensitive at best and lazy at worst.” Perhaps this is because, as the article astutely points out, we “want flexibility, access to decision making and a return to the sacredness of work-free weekends.”

We “want constant feedback from supervisors.” As a generation, we “crave grades, performance evaluations and reviews” because “younger people are not driven from within, they need reinforcement.”

You’ve Heard All This About Gen Y Before, Right?

I was thinking the same thing when reading that article: “Just one more old person bitching about the young… perpetuating the same ‘Battle of the Generations’.”  As if on cue, the article then said “They’re the next big thing. Boomers, beware! It’s payback time!”

Way to add fuel to the fire, Time.

Does all this bickering between the generations ever get us anywhere?

“Can’t We All Just Get Along?”

Boomers: It’s time to move on. Time to grow up. Time to realize that discrimination in this form regarding nearly any other issue would not be tolerated.

Gen Y: I challenge you to step up and be the “bigger man”, as it were. End the generational bickering, and just accept the differences and work toward working together.

Gen X: Oh… I might have neglected to mention…

The Time Magazine article at the beginning of this post… it was written in 1990. Twenty years ago. And the “us” and “we” I referred to was not Gen Y, but my generation… Generation X.

Yes, Gen Y. You Are Different.

You are unique and talented and special… as individuals. But the fact that with a metaphorical wave of a Boomer’s hand you are categorized with disparaging adjectives as a generation… you are no different than Gen X that came before you and perhaps no different than Gen Z (or whatever the next generation will be labeled) after you.

Unless you want to be.

Some day, you may be sitting in your corner office complaining about “those damn Gen AA kids… lazy, spoiled, entitled… with their jet packs and their family-work-life-balance vacations on the moon…”

Or maybe you will truly be different. You’ll have accepted my challenge and embraced our differences. You’ll have made a decision not to perpetuate the battle between the generations.

You’ll have made the difference in the world that is so important to your generation.

Wait… wasn’t that what they said at Woodstock?

The author, Dave Ellis, is an original member of the YouTern team and instrumental to its success… in fact, he’s so awesome there wouldn’t be a YouTern without him (and he might have written this bio himself). In his spare time, Dave volunteers, rescuing and rehabilitating sea lions and baby elephant seals.

This entry was posted in Advice, Gen Y and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • Alyssa

    Great post! As a Gen-Yer, I get so annoyed with all the hating when every generation has gone through this stage of their life in a similar way (moving home, taking a year off, etc.). I also never understood the most common complaint that Gen Y workers are always wanting feedback. Isn’t that a good thing? I want to know if I’m doing my job right or screwing up.

    • http://youtern.com youtern

      Thanks! That’s what I was thinking when I wrote it. I kept hearing comments from Gen Y who thought they were alone with this phenomenon. But I remembered hearing the same things about myself when I entered the workforce a few years back.

      The pattern will repeat until people learn to stop it. Hopefully Gen Y will be the last to face this.

  • JamesClarkNYC

    I was wondering when you were going to admit that you are so not “Gen Y”. It is pretty simple to me: as we get older, we get more set in our ways and less comfortable with the habits, choices, beliefs and points of view of younger folks — from politics to music to work. This article is something of a universal truth (from the calcified POV of the elder) and can (will?) be re-written with the same theme every ten years or so. I say, ignore it, go find what you want, and don’t let yourself be defined. Remember, those same codgers saying “yeah, damn straight” to this article were rolling around naked in the mud at Woodstock…

  • Bob Johnson

    Great post!

    It’s amazing how young people today feel they’re the first to have hardships. But the exact same pressures were felt by the generation before them. It would be great if this whole debate just went away.

  • http://www.daremytruth.com Sass

    Great article – having recently left a fortune 500 financial institution after a couple years of service, I can say that I felt like my ‘Gen Y’ tendencies (wanting to save the world, wanting feedback, recognition and a challenge) were not warmly embraced amongst most long-time managers belonging to another generation, but very much understood by my peer group. I feel like the culture of the company perpetuated that, more than the mere Us (Gen Y) vs.Them (Boomer) phenomenon.

    Each generation is going to be more forward thinking than the last, based on the fact that most individuals want to improve upon or do different than the ones that came before them and that they were exposed to different environmental forces that influenced their thought and behavior on a collective level. So I agree that this cycle has perpetuated for decades and will likely continue and we should all just accept the nuances of each new generation and move on.

    I think if more companies looked at the virtues of Gen Y and created an environment suited to them, all parties would benefit, including the bottom line. I’m now looking at start up and entrepreneurial ventures (as are many of my peers) because they are more innovative and forward thinking in general (of course there are always exceptions to every rule/stereotype outlined in this post).

  • http://www.facebook.com/pages/Standing-out-in-a-Sea-of-Sameness/121653664553169?v=wall Dave Rothacker

    “…you are no different than…” “Unless you want to be.”

    Not to over dramatize this Dave, but this might be one of the most powerful and helpful set of words I’ve ever seen addressed to Gen-Y.

    I view generational rhetoric as a type of framework. If something I read syncs with something I experience, then the neural pathway in my brain where it resides, becomes a little deeper. The more it happens the deeper the rut.

    If I’m working with a Gen-Y age person and his behavior is similar to what’s been dumped in the generational label bucket, then in my mind, he’s reinforced the label.

    But if I’m working with a Gen-Y’er who doesn’t fit the stereotype – she stands out, she leaps from that rut in my mind and creates a whole new neural pathway of possibility. She gets the edge.

    If I’m a Gen-Yer and I have an awareness of a negative label, I can proceed accordingly and use that to my advantage.